Eric Boggs
As Ohio State prepares to take on the Marshall Thundering Herd, this game presents a classic David vs. Goliath matchup. Both teams come into this contest with different goals and expectations, but the narrative is clear: Marshall is facing one of the most formidable teams in the country, while Ohio State continues its quest for a playoff berth.
Ohio State’s Defensive Dominance
Through the first two games of the season, Ohio State has been nearly impenetrable on defense, allowing only two field goals and keeping every opponent out of the red zone. Anchored by a deep, talented roster with potential All-Americans at multiple positions, the Buckeyes have proven to be one of the top defensive teams in the nation.
This depth will be crucial as they prepare for tougher competition, with fans hoping that Marshall can test Ohio State’s defense by breaking into the red zone. For the Buckeyes, this game will be a valuable opportunity to sharpen their skills ahead of key matchups in the Big Ten and their highly anticipated game against Oregon.
Marshall’s Defense Faces a Buckeye Test
Marshall’s defense, their strongest asset so far this season, will have its hands full against Ohio State’s high-powered offense. The Thundering Herd nearly shut down Virginia Tech’s offense in their last game, controlling quarterback Kyron Drones and keeping the Hokies in check for most of the contest. However, facing a team with Ohio State’s talent and depth is an entirely different challenge.
The Herd’s defensive line is led by standout defensive end Mike Green, who has recorded three sacks in two games. A transfer from Virginia, Green will be key in disrupting Ohio State’s offensive rhythm. Alongside him is linebacker Jayden Yates, son of Marshall Hall of Famer Max Yates, and Landon Watson, a TCU transfer who posted 12 tackles against Virginia Tech. While Marshall’s defense is solid, their secondary will face its toughest test yet against Ohio State’s dynamic passing attack.
Offensive Struggles for the Herd
Marshall’s offense has been inconsistent this season, particularly at the quarterback position, as they adjust to a new air raid system. While there have been moments of brilliance, like Christian Fitzpatrick’s one-handed catch against Virginia Tech that made SportsCenter’s Top 10, the offense has yet to establish a consistent rhythm against FBS opponents.
The running game has been a committee effort, with Jordan Houston and AJ Turner leading the charge. Turner, who had a 69-yard run against Virginia Tech, provides some explosiveness, but Marshall’s offense will need more than flashes of potential to keep up with the Buckeyes.
Marshall Fans’ Realistic Expectations
Marshall fans are well aware of the challenge their team faces. Russ, a dedicated Marshall supporter, sees the odds stacked heavily against them. “There’s just no way that we can pull off the victory,” he admits, noting that ESPN gives Marshall just a 3.1% chance to win. Russ is more focused on Marshall earning respect on the national stage, predicting a 41-14 Ohio State victory—a scoreline that would at least showcase Marshall’s resilience.
Another fan, Katie, echoes this sentiment but is focused on the long-term picture for Marshall. “This is a great game… but we have bigger fish to fry,” she says, alluding to the upcoming Sun Belt conference schedule. With Marshall expected to compete for a conference championship, staying healthy and using this game as a learning experience is key. Like Russ, Katie predicts a 45-14 final score in favor of the Buckeyes.
Marshall’s Special Teams and the David vs. Goliath Parallel
Head coach Charles Huff, who has previous experience upsetting Ohio State from his days at Penn State, knows special teams could play a critical role. However, Marshall’s special teams have been inconsistent, with shaky performances in field goals and punting. In a game as high-stakes as this one, any special teams mistakes could be disastrous for the Herd.
There is a small glimmer of hope for Marshall fans who recall their team’s stunning upset of Notre Dame in 2022. While an upset over Ohio State would be even more shocking, there are still comparisons being drawn. However, Marshall fans and analysts recognize that Ohio State’s talent level is far superior to Notre Dame’s, making this an even steeper hill to climb.
Buckeyes March Forward
Ohio State’s depth and talent are undeniable, and this game offers a chance for younger players to get valuable reps in a high-energy environment. While the outcome seems clear, the game provides the Buckeyes with another opportunity to build momentum as they aim for a College Football Playoff spot.
For Marshall, it’s a chance to compete against one of the best programs in the country, gain experience, and prove themselves on the national stage. Even in what looks like an uphill battle, the Herd will aim to show resilience, keep the game respectable, and leave Ohio Stadium with their heads held high.
