The OHIO Podcast’s Report Card: Buckeyes Dominate Marshall, But Defense Faces Questions

Ohio State fans can breathe a sigh of relief after the Buckeyes’ solid 49-14 win over Marshall, but there’s still plenty to dissect from the game. Starting with the offense, Ohio State lit up the scoreboard with 569 total yards, including 280 on the ground and 289 through the air. Quarterback Will Howard was efficient, completing 80% of his passes for 275 yards and two touchdowns, but he also threw an interception. However, as fans pointed out, it was an aggressive mistake, a risk worth taking as the Buckeyes continue to push the downfield passing game.

Running back Quinshon Judkins led the way with a monstrous 173 yards on just 14 carries, adding two touchdowns in a performance that averaged nearly 13 yards per carry. TreVeyon Henderson chipped in with 76 yards and two more touchdowns, while receiver Emeka Egbuka was a standout with five catches for 117 yards and a touchdown. Jeremiah Smith had a highlight-reel 68-yard score off a bubble screen, a play reminiscent of the explosive offenses from the Urban Meyer era.

Despite the offensive fireworks, fans and analysts alike were not fully satisfied, with many grading the unit an “A” instead of an A+. The interception and occasional lack of involvement from key players like Smith kept some from giving out perfect marks.

On defense, the Buckeyes held Marshall to 264 total yards but allowed the Thundering Herd to convert 7 of 17 third downs, sustain long drives, and score two offensive touchdowns—the first Ohio State has conceded this season. The lack of a pass rush was a major concern, as Ohio State only managed one sack against a group of five opponent.

Linebacker play was also scrutinized, with Sonny Styles struggling in coverage. Safety Lathan Ransom was a bright spot, leading the team with eight tackles. However, the Buckeyes failed to force any turnovers, something they’ll need to address moving forward.

Overall, fans graded the defense harshly, with many giving it a “C” for the lackluster pressure and inability to get off the field on third down. Despite the win, the slow starts and ongoing issues against mobile quarterbacks left fans concerned, especially with tougher opponents on the horizon.

Ohio State has plenty to be proud of after a decisive win, but as always, the expectations in Columbus are sky-high, and fans know there’s still work to be done.