Eric Boggs
The debate over quarterback rankings in the NFL Draft is an annual tradition, and this year, it has sparked a heated discussion between two former Ohio State quarterbacks: Will Howard and Kyle McCord. As scouts and analysts evaluate talent, the question arises—why do some quarterbacks, despite leading their teams to national championships, find themselves ranked lower than those from lesser programs?
This was the very question posed by Australian Buckeye fan Matthew Butcher, who questioned why quarterbacks like Howard, a championship-winning leader at Ohio State, might not be as highly regarded as others, such as Shedeur Sanders or Cameron Ward. The answer lies in the NFL’s scouting process, which tends to prioritize physical attributes and raw measurables over intangible leadership qualities and on-field success.
The NFL’s Draft Evaluation Process
NFL scouts are hired to analyze players based on their potential fit within a team’s system. Factors like arm strength, hand size, accuracy, and athletic measurables often outweigh college success. This has led to cases like Tim Tebow, one of the greatest college quarterbacks of all time, struggling at the professional level because his skill set did not translate well to the NFL. Similarly, quarterbacks with elite physical tools but questionable leadership skills may receive higher draft grades, regardless of their collegiate performance.
Why Kyle McCord Ranks Higher Than Will Howard
Many draft experts have placed Kyle McCord ahead of Will Howard in their mock drafts, citing McCord’s arm strength and statistical improvement after transferring to Syracuse. McCord’s numbers jumped significantly in 2024, making him an attractive option for NFL teams looking for a quarterback with a strong arm.
However, critics argue that McCord lacks the intangibles necessary to lead an NFL team. His interactions with Ohio State head coach Ryan Day in 2023 painted a picture of a quarterback who struggled to handle constructive criticism and adversity. Leadership, presence in the huddle, and the ability to inspire teammates are traits that do not show up on a stat sheet but are crucial for long-term success in the NFL.
Will Howard’s Strengths and NFL Projection
Unlike McCord, Howard has built a reputation as a tough, resilient leader. Despite having a terrible game against Michigan, Howard’s grit and determination endeared him to fans and teammates alike. His ability to command the huddle and remain composed under pressure is a valuable asset that NFL teams should not overlook.
While Howard may not possess the elite arm talent of McCord, his leadership and ability to adapt to different offensive systems suggest he could have a long career as a reliable backup—and possibly even develop into a starter in the right situation. Many scouts believe he has the makings of an eight-to-ten-year career in the league, even if he is not drafted as high as McCord.
The Risk of Drafting McCord
Despite his physical gifts, McCord carries significant concerns. His departure from Ohio State following an unsuccessful meeting with Ryan Day—where he and his father reportedly requested guaranteed starting status—raises questions about his mentality. Additionally, McCord’s struggles in big-game situations and lack of natural leadership make him a risky selection for any NFL team looking for a future franchise quarterback.
Final Thoughts
The NFL Draft process is often flawed, with teams overvaluing physical traits while undervaluing leadership and toughness. History has shown that intangibles matter just as much, if not more, than arm strength or hand size. While McCord may be drafted higher than Howard, there is a strong argument that Howard’s long-term prospects in the NFL are brighter.
As teams finalize their draft boards, they would be wise to remember that the best quarterbacks are not always the ones with the strongest arms—but rather the ones who possess the heart, leadership, and resilience to thrive at the next level.
