Eric Boggs
Few programs in college football history boast the pedigree and tradition of Ohio State. From Heisman Trophy winners to national champions, the Buckeyes have long been a powerhouse. But which true freshmen—those who stepped onto the field in their first year and made an immediate impact—stand among the greatest in school history? The OHIO Podcast recently tackled this question, and after in-depth debate and analysis, a consensus Mount Rushmore of all-time Ohio State true freshmen emerged. Let’s take a closer look at these legendary first-year players.
Jeremiah Smith (2023)
The inspiration behind this discussion, Jeremiah Smith, had a record-breaking season in 2023 that left an indelible mark on Ohio State history. The freshman wide receiver shattered school records, tallying 76 receptions, 1,315 yards, and 15 touchdowns—surpassing marks previously set by Buckeye greats like Cris Carter. His postseason performance was just as remarkable, delivering game-changing moments against Tennessee, Oregon, and Notre Dame, including a clutch late-game catch that secured victory. Without question, Smith’s dominance as a true freshman earns him a spot on this esteemed list.
Maurice Clarett (2002)
Perhaps the most controversial selection due to his short-lived college career, Maurice Clarett’s impact in 2002 remains undeniable. As a true freshman running back, Clarett rushed for 1,237 yards and 16 touchdowns in just 11 games, leading Ohio State to an undefeated season and a national championship. His iconic strip of Miami’s Sean Taylor in the Fiesta Bowl epitomized his relentless will to win and helped secure the Buckeyes’ first national title since 1968. Despite off-field struggles, Clarett’s freshman season remains one of the most significant in Ohio State history.
Andy Katzenmoyer (1996)
Nicknamed “The Big Kat,” Andy Katzenmoyer was a game-changer at linebacker from the moment he stepped on campus in 1996. His freshman stat line was staggering: 85 tackles, 12 sacks, 23 tackles for loss, four interceptions, and three forced fumbles. He even notched a pick in the Rose Bowl. His rare blend of size, speed, and power made him a nightmare for opposing offenses and cemented his place as one of the most dominant defensive players in Buckeye history. Ohio State has had many elite linebackers, but Katzenmoyer’s immediate impact makes him stand out.
Orlando Pace (1994)
The undisputed George Washington of this Mount Rushmore, Orlando Pace revolutionized offensive line play. The dominant left tackle became so imposing that analysts created a new stat—the “pancake block”—to measure his effectiveness. Pace was a force from day one, leading the way for Heisman winner Eddie George and setting a standard for future offensive linemen. His legacy extends beyond Ohio State, as he went on to an illustrious NFL career, earning induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. His greatness as a freshman and beyond makes him the most deserving selection on this list.
Honorable Mentions
While these four stood out as consensus picks, Ohio State has had several other legendary freshmen. Players like Archie Griffin, Ted Ginn Jr., J.K. Dobbins, and Terrelle Pryor all had impressive first-year performances and could certainly make a case for inclusion.
Final Thoughts
Selecting just four players for Ohio State’s all-time true freshman Mount Rushmore is no easy task. However, Jeremiah Smith, Maurice Clarett, Andy Katzenmoyer, and Orlando Pace each left an undeniable impact on Buckeye history in their first seasons. Whether through record-breaking performances, championship heroics, or redefining their positions, these four stand among the greatest to ever don the Scarlet and Gray.
Do you agree with this list? Who else deserves a spot? Let us know your thoughts.
