Eric Boggs
As the 2024 NFL Draft approaches, Ohio State fans are eager to see a record number of Buckeyes hear their names called on draft night. One of the most intriguing debates surrounding this year’s class is who should be the first Ohio State player selected: left tackle Josh Simmons or versatile offensive lineman Donovan Jackson?
The Case for Josh Simmons
Josh Simmons, formerly known as Jimmy Simmons, emerged as one of the most improved players on Ohio State’s roster last season. After transferring from San Diego State, Simmons quickly became a reliable presence on the offensive line before suffering a season-ending injury in the Oregon game. Despite playing only six games in 2023, his performance was strong enough to warrant first-round consideration in many mock drafts.
Simmons opted to undergo surgery and rehab away from the team, following a path similar to former Buckeye Nick Bosa. While some fans may question his decision to distance himself from the program during recovery, Simmons appears to be ahead of schedule in his rehabilitation. His talent and potential at left tackle—a premium position in the NFL—make him a logical choice as the first Buckeye off the board.
The Case for Donovan Jackson
While Simmons has drawn early first-round buzz, Donovan Jackson presents a compelling argument for being the top Buckeye drafted. The former five-star recruit demonstrated incredible versatility throughout his Ohio State career, excelling at left guard but also stepping in at left tackle when needed during the College Football Playoff run. His ability to play multiple positions along the offensive line gives him added value at the next level.
Jackson’s durability is another key factor. Unlike Simmons, Jackson remained on the field throughout the season, proving his resilience and dependability. His consistent availability and high level of play could make him an attractive option for NFL teams seeking a long-term solution on the offensive line. Most mock drafts project Jackson as a late first-round or early second-round pick, but his stock could rise depending on team needs and pre-draft workouts.
Evaluating the Debate
Simmons’ status as a natural left tackle makes him a highly coveted prospect, as NFL teams always prioritize protecting their quarterback’s blind side. However, Jackson’s versatility and durability could ultimately make him a more valuable long-term investment.
For Ohio State fans, the debate boils down to preference. Do you prioritize the premium position of left tackle, or do you favor the flexibility and reliability of a player like Jackson? While both players will make their mark at the next level, the decision ultimately rests with NFL general managers, who must weigh talent, injury history, and positional value.
Regardless of who gets drafted first, Buckeye Nation will undoubtedly be cheering for both players as they take the next step in their football careers. As the draft nears, the conversation continues: Josh Simmons or Donovan Jackson—who should be the first Buckeye off the board?
