Eric Boggs
Ohio State’s presence at the top of college football was reinforced once again as eight Buckeyes earned spots on the Associated Press All-America teams for the 2025 season, the most selections of any program in the country. From explosive playmakers on offense to tone-setters on a dominant defense, the honors reflect a roster that continues to define excellence in Columbus.
Wide receiver Jeremiah Smith, defensive tackle Kayden McDonald, linebacker Arvell Reese and safety Caleb Downs were each named first-team AP All-Americans, an achievement that places them one step closer to consensus All-America status. All four were also selected to the Walter Camp All-America team, meaning just one additional first-team nod from the AFCA, Sporting News or the Football Writers Association of America would cement their place as consensus selections.
Smith’s first-team recognition comes after another standout season in scarlet and gray. He hauled in 80 receptions for 1,086 yards and 11 touchdowns through the regular season and Big Ten Championship Game, becoming only the third wide receiver in Ohio State history to post multiple 1,000-yard seasons. His consistency and big-play ability once again made him one of the most feared weapons in the country.
Downs continued to be the heartbeat of Ohio State’s top-ranked defense, anchoring the secondary while making his impact felt all over the field. The star safety totaled 60 tackles, five tackles for loss, two interceptions, two pass breakups and a sack, keeping him firmly in the conversation to become just the sixth Buckeye ever to earn unanimous All-America honors twice.
In the trenches, McDonald emerged as a force at nose tackle, disrupting opposing offenses on a weekly basis. He finished the season with 57 tackles, eight tackles for loss, three sacks and two forced fumbles, embodying the physical identity that has long defined Ohio State’s defensive front. Reese was equally impactful at linebacker, piling up 62 tackles, 10 tackles for loss, 6.5 sacks and two pass breakups while serving as the steady leader in the middle of the defense.
Ohio State’s All-America recognition extended beyond the first team as well. Wide receiver Carnell Tate and linebacker Sonny Styles earned second-team AP honors, while quarterback Julian Sayin and defensive end Caden Curry were named to the third team, underscoring the depth and balance of the Buckeyes’ roster.
With the AFCA All-America team set to be announced Tuesday, followed by Sporting News on Wednesday and the FWAA on Thursday, Ohio State fans will be watching closely as several Buckeyes look to turn an already impressive haul of honors into consensus All-America distinction.
