Eric Boggs
As Buckeye fans, we take pride in analyzing every detail of our team’s performance. With the season in full swing, it’s time for an honest assessment of each position group as Ohio State makes its push toward the playoffs. Here’s a breakdown of how the Buckeyes have fared so far:
Quarterback: Will Howard – Grade: A-
Ohio State’s quarterback, Will Howard, has exceeded expectations this season. Completing 73% of his passes, Howard has proven he’s more than just a game manager. Despite a few turnovers, such as the interception against Michigan State, his leadership and football IQ have stood out, especially during the high-pressure matchup against Oregon. His ability to keep the offense moving, even when the defense struggled, shows he can rise to the occasion when it matters most. Howard’s quick thinking, like getting the offense set to avoid a review, reflects his awareness on the field. Though not perfect, Howard has been a blessing for the Buckeyes, and fans can feel confident with him at the helm.
Running Backs – Grade: A-
The running back group, led by Quinshon Judkins and James Peoples, has been a strong point for Ohio State, combining for 10 touchdowns this season. Though productive, there have been hiccups, such as their quiet second half against Oregon where they managed only 19 yards on 12 carries. Judkins’ fumble in that game was a momentum changer, though it’s important to note he was playing through a hand injury. With his minor surgery behind him, the hope is that he will return to full strength. Despite these setbacks, the explosive potential and solid pass protection have kept the group in the A- range.
Wide Receivers – Grade: A-
Ohio State’s wide receiver corps has been one of the brightest spots this season, with Jeremiah Smith leading the way. Smith’s ability to win 50-50 balls has been crucial, but as a unit, there are still moments where they could step up more consistently. Their overall performance earns them an A-, but with their talent and continued development, this group could easily push for a higher grade as the season progresses.
Tight Ends – Grade: C+
The tight end group has been serviceable but far from exceptional. G. Scott Jr. has shown flashes of potential, including a key catch to open the Oregon game, but inconsistency in blocking has limited this unit’s effectiveness. Jelani Thurman’s development has been slower than expected, and the absence of Chasmeric raises questions about the group’s depth. With the potential still there, especially with Thurman’s All-American upside, more production is needed to elevate their grade.
Offensive Line – Grade: A-
Ohio State’s offensive line has shown solid play, though consistency remains an issue. They’ve provided good protection for Will Howard and opened running lanes, but against elite competition, they’ll need to find another gear. Overall, their performance has earned them an A-, with the potential to rise if they can sustain their play through tougher matchups.
Defensive Ends – Grade: B+
Jack Sawyer and J.T. Tuimoloau have had their moments, with J.T.’s Superman sack being a season highlight. However, their overall impact has been limited by the scheme. While the potential for dominance is there, a bit more consistency is needed. The defensive ends earn a B+, but a few more standout performances could bump that grade up.
Defensive Tackles – Grade: B+
Tyleik Williams and Ty Hamilton have been anchors in the middle of the defensive line, playing a key role in stopping the run. Their ability to clog the middle and control the line of scrimmage has been crucial for the defense’s success. With both players showcasing NFL potential, their B+ grade reflects a strong, dependable group on the verge of reaching an A if they continue their stellar play.
Linebackers – Grade: C
Linebacker play has been a point of frustration for Buckeye fans. While Cody Simon provides solid leadership, the unit overall has been inconsistent. The legendary linebacker legacy at Ohio State sets a high standard, and this group hasn’t lived up to it yet. Gabe Powers and Arvell Reese have shown flashes of promise, but the 4-2-5 scheme may be limiting their ability to shine. Until the intensity and production improve, this group will stay at a C.
Cornerbacks – Grade: B-
The cornerbacks have had a rollercoaster season. Prior to the Oregon game, they were playing at an A-plus level, but that game exposed some weaknesses. Denzel Burke had a rough outing, which dropped the group’s grade, but overall, the cornerbacks have shown great potential. With the pass rush improving, we can expect this unit to bounce back and improve their B- grade.
Safeties – Grade: A
The safeties have arguably been the brightest spot on Ohio State’s defense this season. Josh Proctor, Sonny Styles, and Lathan Ransom have been the most sound tacklers on the team, acting as safety valves against big plays, especially in the run game. Even when opponents break through to the second level, the Buckeyes can count on their safeties to clean up. Malik Hartford and Kye Stokes have also contributed well in limited action. While the group has had its occasional missteps, overall, they’ve been fundamental to the defense’s success. With Tim Walton coaching this talented room, they’ve earned a solid A for their efforts this season.
Final Thoughts
As we look toward the rest of the season, Ohio State has all the pieces needed to contend for a championship. The talent is there on both sides of the ball, from Will Howard’s leadership at quarterback to the dynamic playmakers in the running back and wide receiver rooms. Defensively, the Buckeyes are solid, with room to improve in the linebacker and secondary units. If everything comes together, Buckeye Nation can expect a strong push for the playoffs. Let’s get after it! Go Bucks!
