Eric Boggs
In a classic offseason tradition for Buckeye Nation, Chris Wilds—better known as “The Wild Man” on The OHIO Podcast—brought fire and fervor to the debate that keeps fans talking long after the final whistle: who are the top quarterbacks in Ohio State history?
With Julian Sayin poised to become the next great leader under center in Columbus, Wilds dusted off the archives and fed a custom algorithm a mix of career stats, big-game performances, and legacy moments to deliver a definitive top 10 list. And while some fans may argue over who deserved a higher spot or question the inclusion of short-tenured stars, one thing is certain: this list celebrates the legacy of excellence at the quarterback position for the Scarlet and Gray.
Topping the list was none other than 2006 Heisman Trophy winner Troy Smith. Smith finished his career with a sterling 25-3 record as a starter, four wins over Michigan, and one of the most iconic performances in program history—the epic No. 1 vs. No. 2 showdown in 2006 where he torched the Wolverines for over 300 yards and three touchdowns. Smith wasn’t just a stat-stuffer; he was a leader who captured the heart of Buckeye Nation, and though a national championship eluded him, his legacy as the quintessential Ohio State quarterback is cemented.
Coming in at number two was J.T. Barrett, whose steady hand and unmatched leadership kept the Buckeyes in national contention year after year. With a 4-0 record against Michigan and two Big Ten titles, Barrett exemplified toughness and consistency. He may not have had the arm of a C.J. Stroud or the highlight reel of a Justin Fields, but his command of the offense and resilience in big games earned him a rightful place among the greats.
Justin Fields landed at number three, remembered for his electric playmaking ability and that unforgettable six-touchdown effort against Clemson in the 2021 CFP semifinal. Fields, though only a two-year starter, made every snap count. His toughness, particularly in that bruising win over Clemson, left a lasting impression on fans who wished he had just a bit more time—or luck—to bring home a national title.
At number four was C.J. Stroud, one of the most technically gifted passers the program has ever seen. His 2022 Peach Bowl performance against Georgia, despite ending in a loss, remains one of the most heroic quarterback efforts in school history. However, an 0-2 mark against Michigan kept him from climbing higher on Wilds’ list.
Rounding out the top five was the late Dwayne Haskins, whose lone season as starter in 2018 saw him set a new school record for passing yards and lay waste to Michigan’s defense in The Game. While his time was short, Haskins’ brilliance was undeniable.
Braxton Miller, the electrifying dual-threat QB who helped redefine the Buckeye offense, came in at number six. Injuries may have cut short his time at quarterback, but his legacy—including a perfect 3-0 record against Michigan and highlight reel moments galore—was more than enough to earn a spot.
Next on the list was Craig Krenzel, the game manager turned national champion. His numbers were never flashy, but his leadership and knack for clutch plays—especially the legendary Holy Buckeye pass—made him a fan favorite and a winner.
At number eight, Cardale Jones proved that sometimes a short run can leave a long-lasting impact. His flawless 11-0 record, including a magical three-game stretch that brought home the 2014 national title, earned him a well-deserved place.
Number nine sparked some debate, as Will Howard was the most recent name on the list and one with a relatively brief tenure. But Wilds highlighted Howard’s clutch performances in postseason play and his key role in a national title run as justification for his inclusion—despite a loss to Michigan.
Rounding out the list at number ten was Art Schlichter, a throwback to an era when the Buckeyes leaned on the run. Still, Schlichter’s dual-threat ability and more than 6,000 passing yards made him ahead of his time and worthy of mention.
As Chris Wilds acknowledged, this list is bound to spark debate. Whether you side with Team Troy, argue for more love for CJ, or believe Braxton’s magic should’ve ranked higher, every fan has a voice in Buckeye Nation. And with Sayin waiting in the wings, the next chapter in Ohio State quarterback history is just beginning.
So the question remains: who’s your GOAT Buckeye QB? Let the debate rage on, and as always—Go Bucks!
